Talk Isn’t Cheap
This week, AI has made talk easier than ever. That doesn’t make it cheap.
This week, AI has made talk easier than ever. That doesn’t make it cheap.
When I Googled the meaning of "talk is cheap", the AI summary shared that it is “a common idiom meaning that it is easy to say you will do something, but actually doing it requires real work, time, and effort.”
Today, talking about doing something, creating a strategy or plan, is even cheaper as we don’t need to put any effort into the talking bit, let alone the doing bit, as we have AI to generate oodles of this talk stuff.
In a delicious irony based on the topic of this post - and pretty much all the posts I am writing these days - the Google summary was attributed to Merriam-Webster, but the actual dictionary entry says “used to mean that it is easy to say that one will do something”. The rest it made up on its own.
But, I digress. I don’t actually agree that “talk is cheap” when it comes to doing any meaningful planning or strategy; the talk bit requires investment. The talk bit has value.
Yes, in sales and marketing, we could have our robot assistant create our ideal customer profile, buyer personas, or target accounts, but who would give a shit about that generic document or bother to read it?
As I’ve talked about before, when it comes to writing, the journey of doing it is as much a part of the value of doing the thing as the thing that pops out the other end. Leaning on a robot to write for you robs you of that learning journey.
And I think it’s the same when we skip the friction of getting a group of people to agree on something.
If you’ve argued that a buyer has a specific need, mentally sat in their seat and convinced someone to write that on the whiteboard, it’s going to stick.
And there is some psychology that supports this.
You’ve probably heard of the IKEA effect, where we value something more when we build it or collaborate in building it.
There’s also the generation effect: writing something yourself, rather than hearing or reading it, helps it stick, which is why some folks swear by taking notes in meetings even if they never look at them again.
And, no surprise, it turns out we’re far more convinced by an argument we’ve made ourselves than one we’ve just heard.
The “deliverable” from a planning exercise isn’t ticking the box of producing a document. It’s a shared understanding and ownership of the thing at hand that a document generated by a robot assistant can’t give you.